.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Emet m'Tsiyon

Monday, October 22, 2007

Arab leaders had helped the Nazi Mass Murderers in the Holocaust

Walt-Mearsheimer argue in their book, The Israel Lobby, that when Arab leaders called for "throwing the Jews into the sea," back in 1947-1948, they didn't really mean it [see earlier post]. This is ridiculous. I mentioned in an updating to that post that there was a historical precedent for driving a hated ethnic group into the sea. This happened at Smyrna in 1922, when the Turkish nationalist army, supported in various ways by both Western capitalist powers and the new, "revolutionary" anti-capitalist Soviet Union, drove Greeks into the sea [see here].

Another reason that the walt-mearsheimer claim is ridiculous, more important in fact than that there was a precedent for driving people into the sea, was the collaboration of Arab nationalist, pan-Arabist, and Arab pan-Islamist leaders with the Nazis in general and with the Holocaust in particular. The chief Arab Nazi collaborator was Haj Amin el-Husseini [al-Husayni], the British-appointed mufti of Jerusalem and the head of the Supreme Muslim Council in "palestine," a body set up by the British which had not existed before. Indeed the name "palestine" [or Filastin] had not been used by the Ottoman or Mamluk empires which ruled the country between the Crusades and the British conquest in 1917.

Somehow, Husseini, who was often called simply "the Mufti" when he was active and people knew who he was, has been forgotten. By "forgetting" Husseini anti-Israel propagandists in the guise of academics, of "leftists" or of statesmen, can pretend that the Arabs, the palestinian Arabs in particular, were innocent in the Holocaust and that therefore the Jews/Zionists were unfairly punishing the "palestinians" for what was a German or European crime. The truth is that the Arab nationalists collaborated in the Holocaust in Europe, Husseini in particular, and also slaughtered Jews in the Arab countries [search for Farhud on this blog]. Such massacres took place in Iraq, Libya, and elsewhere. Anwar Sadat and Gamal Abdul-Nasser and their Free Officers coterie collaborated with the Nazis. Even after the war, both Sadat and Nasser proudly affirmed their admiration for Hitler. In his book, Revolt on the Nile, Sadat expressed regret that the Nazis lost the war, and in particular he blamed Egyptian Jews for causing his and Nasser's pro-Nazi plot, in the framework of the Free Officers, to fail.

Husseini's role was described in 1947 by Bartley Crum, a noted American liberal and member of the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry on Palestine [1946].
Sir Frederick [a British member of the Anglo-American Committee] and I visited the war trials while we were in Nuremberg, and I spent some time talking to the American investigators who were reconstructing the Nazi conspiracy, for the prosecution, from the massive archives which the Allies had unearthed.
I remembered Edgar Ansel Mowrer's scoop in London when he printed the text of an affidavit that incriminated the ex-Mufti [Husseini] in the mass murder of the Jews. I understood that there was a large file on the Mufti in the archives of the Allied War Crimes Commission . . .
. . . I visited Jackson [Mr Justice Jackson, Chief United States Prosecutor at the Nuremberg International War Crimes Tribunal] the next day. I mentioned the Mowrer affidavit to him. He replied that he was familiar with it, but . . . I could see that the subject was unpleasant to him, so I dropped it.
There were others much interested in seeing that the Mufti's story was told. An Army intelligence officer, at three o'clock one afternoon, made it possible for me to enter a room and sit down at a table upon which was a thick file of documents. . .
The record of the ex-Mufti's intrigues was fantastic. This file showed clearly that he had climaxed a record of Fascism, anti-British intrigues, and anti-Semitism by helping spearhead the extermination of European Jewry. I had my hands on a German document signed by an agent of the Mufti scarcely twenty-four hours before Germany surrendered. . . Adolf Eichmann, the Gestapo specialist in Jewish affairs, who had been the confidant of the Mufti. . . And Nazi records show that, accompanied by Eichmann, the Grand Mufti, incognito, visited the gas chambers of Auschwitz. . . ". . . the extermination of European Jewry." The Mufti told Wisliczeny [Dieter von Wisliczeny, a Nazi war criminal] that he "considered this [extermination] a comfortble solution to the Palestine problem." . . . Hitler had instructed that in any ransoming of concentration camp inmates, no Jews were to be included because an agreement had been reached with the Mufti that all Jews be exterminated. . . Negotiations were under way at that time for the ransom of the Jewish community of Bratislava. These negotiations broke down because the Mufti refused to countenance their being ransomed and as a result the entire community was liquidated. . . A letter from the Mufti to Foreign Minister von Ribbentrop, on July 25, 1944, complained of German clemency toward the Jews. . .
. . . On June 5, 1943, he protested to the Prime Minister of Bulgaria [an Axis ally] against a plan by the Bulgarian government allowing emigration [from the Nazi-fascist zones] of four thousand Jewish children. These children, he argued, presented "a degree of danger to Bulgaria whether they be kept in Bulgaria or be permitted to depart from that country." Instead, he said, they should be sent to a place in which they would be "under stringent control --as for instance, Poland." The Mufti's protest was successful. No children's transport left Bulgaria after July, 1943. [Bartley C Crum, Behind the Silken Curtain (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1947), pp 109-112]
Husseini sent a like letter to the Rumanian foreign minister [Rumania too was an Axis ally]. Instead of letting Jewish children leave the Nazi-fascist domain
This time he again suggested Poland, pointing out that they would be under what he called "active supervision," a euphemism for the gas chambers. [Crum, p 112]
Whereas Husseini eagerly had Jewish children murdered in the Holocaust [ie, sent to Poland where Auschwitz was located], Arab propagandists and sympathizers of the Arab anti-Israel cause, like to accuse Israel of killing Arab children. However, when Arabs are doing the shooting they don't much mind. It seems that when Arabs shoot their own children [see here], that's OK.

Sources on the web for information on Arab collaboration in the Holocaust are here and here, to supply only a few of those sources available.
Remember Bartley Crum's book:
Bartley C Crum, Behind the Silken Curtain (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1947)

Note that Justice Jackson, the American chief prosecutor of the Nuremberg War Crimes Tribunal, did not want to prosecute Husseini. This was policy, the policy of the Big Four war time allies [the US, UK, France, USSR]. Husseini was under supervised residence in France after WW2 from May 1945. He was allowed to leave France in 1946 and return to the Middle East where he resumed his Judeophobic intrigues, including agitating for war on the Jews in Israel. So Walt-Mearsheimer are concealing the evidence when they pretend that the Arabs did not really intend to drive the Jews into the sea in the 1947-49 war. The Arabs --such as the Mufti Husseini-- intended a worse fate for the Jews. The fact that the Allies did not want to prosecute Husseini at Nuremberg --his pro-Holocaust doings notwithstanding-- belie two of Edward Said's usual arguments: 1) the Arabs were and are innocent, especially of harming the Jews, and especially of the Holocaust; 2) the major Western powers were always looking to harm the innocent Arabs, to restrain Arab nationalism, to besmirch Islam, etc.

Another important fact that Walt-Mearsheimer don't deal with is that the Arabs in the various Arab-Muslim-ruled lands oppressed, humiliated, economically exploited the Jews for a period of more than a thousand years. That fact too is significant and various posts on this blog have documented and illustrated it.
- - - - - - - - -
Coming: a top British journalopropagandist in love with walt-mearsheimer, Jews in Jerusalem, Hebron, Land of Israel, peace follies, propaganda, etc.

Labels: , , , ,


  • Outstanding article, keep up the good fight. Shalom

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:26 PM  

  • Thanx,
    תודה רבה

    By Blogger Eliyahu m'Tsiyon, at 6:53 PM  

  • La actitud de los musulmanes en el periodo previo a la segunda guerra mundial y durante la misma es algo que callan muchos de los que debieran hablar, es un hecho cierto que el fascismo fue aplicado y comprendido por estos personajes y a la cabeza de ellos Husseini, pero no han cambiado las cosas tanto desde entonces, siguen practicando ese fascismo, amenazan con el exterminio de Israel de forma constante mientras los llamados musulmanes moderados callan como corderos, por miedo o porque los fines de unos y otros son los mismos.. El silencio no es la respuesta, es necesaria una actitud combativa de todos los que queremos a Israel y de los gobiernos que se llaman democráticos pero que cuando se trata de dinero y otros intereses, como el intento de influencia en las sociedades musulmanas, ya se lo piensan, esa es su democracia. Así nos va en occidente

    By Blogger Iojanan, at 3:03 PM  

  • Iojanan [Yohanan] points out quite correctly that Arab-Nazi collaboration and the copying of fascist ideology and methods by Arabs and other Muslims have been long hushed up by those who should speak about it [I would include here Condoleeza Rice, US secretary of state - Eliyahu]. He points out that exterminating Israel is openly advocated in the Muslim world and that "moderate Muslims" are silent about these matters too, either out of fear or because they share the purposes of the genocidal radicals. He calls for all those who love Israel and for democrratic governments to fight for the right side on these matters. However, he points out that economic interests and the quest for political influence with Muslim states lead the "democracies" to play for their interests and not what is right.

    By Blogger Eliyahu m'Tsiyon, at 9:27 PM  

  • Some very informative and intriguing posts here. Failing to speak of the al-Husseinis of the Arab and Persian Muslim world would be understandable, for diplomatic and other purposes, if such historic figures were but arcane artifacts of some historical past with little or no relevance to contemporary events (e.g., Japan's deification of the Emperor as a direct decendant of the Sun God, as recently as WWII). But precisely the opposite is the case, they are themselves the archimedean pivot points upon which so much of recent and current events are reliant upon and reflective of.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 11:17 PM  

  • After Netanyahu said erroneously that Hitler’s extermination plan came after he met with Mufti, which is totally not true. Hitler, Nazis had the final solution long before , of course.
    Ihaan Tharoor then , in Washington Post wrote a piece in October 22, 2015, taking advantage of Netantahu's words.

    However Tharoor also erred when he tried to minimize why the Mufti allied with Hitler. He intentionally omitted racist Jihadi fatwa by Mufti, his calls over the radio [ https://books.google.com/books?id=i5ITDQAAQBAJ&pg=PP332 , https://books.google.com/books?id=sSEuDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT11 , https://books.google.com/books?id=AsOVAgAAQBAJ&pg=PA75 , https://books.google.com/books?id=lMLmK-fmf8kC&pg=PA20 ] to the Muslim world to “Kill the J.. wherever they are..This pleases Allah.” Not Zionists. But any J. Wherever he is on the planet. Plain and simple.
    That is way beyond any political alliances.
    The ex Mufti of Palestine al-Hussein was anti-Any-Jew and called for extermination.
    Despite Hitler’s demagogic “praise” for this particular Arab’s look and asserting he is not pure Arab in blood...[ https://books.google.com/books?id=3q5dFD61V5oC&pg=PA156 , https://books.google.com/books?id=RHqgAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Veins%22 ], yet, he still refused to shake his hands [ https://books.google.com/books?id=wHSvDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT7 ]
    Have no doubt Hitler would have wiped out Arabs after Jews, 24 February 2007

    By Blogger Actuality, History, at 4:41 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home